All Will Drive

 

Too much monkey business

By Vernon B. Sarne

Thailand is under water. It has been so for months. The ongoing calamity makes Ondoy seem like a drizzle by comparison. It has claimed more than 500 lives and shut down close to 900 factories in various industrial areas, bringing the cost of damages to an estimated $5 billion. The world will no doubt see a drop in the production of hard drives, Thailand being the second-largest producer of these storage devices.

But I think you will agree that the skies won't come crashing down if people don't get to buy another hard drive in the next few months. What worries everyone is the effect of the flooding on the automotive business. Thailand, remember, is the main manufacturing hub of the car industry in the region. The Detroit of Southeast Asia, it is called.

While only Honda saw its manufacturing facility in the province of Ayutthaya literally submerged, the other carmakers with factories in the swamped kingdom also had to halt production activities as their parts suppliers had been deluged themselves. Observers say Filipino consumers will only truly feel the ripple effect of the Thailand flooding come December, when inventories start running out. Somebody with connections inside a Honda dealership in northern Metro Manila told me over the weekend that said dealer was down to its last 30 units--and that no new supplies are expected to arrive anytime soon.

Indeed, the damage inflicted on the car industry by the Japan earthquake and tsunami in March is nothing compared to the grave repercussions of the natural catastrophe in Thailand. Especially since most automakers had put all of their eggs in one basket in the region. So now Filipino industry players can't help but rue the fact that this wide-scale setback could have been averted had car companies put up their manufacturing facilities in the Philippines instead.

"If we produced our best-selling cars here instead of importing them from Thailand, we wouldn't have this problem," said one executive. "Santa Rosa would have been a perfect place to operate a manufacturing plant because it never floods there."

Of course, such a sentiment is unfair because it happens to have the benefit of hindsight. If Santa Rosa were the industry's manufacturing hub in Southeast Asia, and Taal Volcano decided one day to spew molten rocks, well...

Even so, it's a thought worth entertaining.

While several carmakers do have assembly plants here--Ford, Toyota, Isuzu, Honda and Nissan in Santa Rosa, and Mitsubishi in Cainta--their production output is piddling vis-à-vis the overall total in Thailand. What we produce here is just enough for local consumption, almost just a token gesture to show that the industry is investing and creating jobs in the country.

We've long accepted that the reason the car industry's regional manufacturing hub is located in Thailand and not in the Philippines, is because there exists a wide disparity in the market sizes. While we hit a record high of 168,000 units last year, Thailand sold a total of 800,000 brand-new vehicles in the same period. No contest. End of story, right?

Probably. But that is only one side of the coin. The flip side is the oft-neglected fact that the Philippines is simply not conducive to business. We are not attractive to foreign investors, period. This is verified by the World Bank's Doing Business annual report, which aims to measure the ease (or difficulty) of starting, operating and growing a business in a particular country.

In the latest report benchmarked to June this year, 183 economies were included. The higher the ranking of a country, the easier it is to do business there. First on the list is Singapore, followed by Hong Kong, New Zealand, the United States and Denmark. At the very bottom is the Republic of Chad, apparently the seventh-poorest country in the world.

The rankings are determined by 10 factors, including "starting a business," "dealing with construction permits," "getting electricity," "registering property," "getting credit," "protecting investors," "paying taxes," "trading across borders," "enforcing contracts," and "resolving insolvency." Read the factors again and it's almost a given the Philippines will place poorly on the list.

Out of 183 countries, we're ranked 136th overall, worse than the likes of Sudan (135th), Nigeria (133rd), Swaziland (124th), Ethiopia (111th), Pakistan (105th) and Vietnam (98th). We're terribly bad in the area of "starting a business," in which we're ranked 158th. When it comes to "protecting investors" and "dealing with construction permits," we're just as unreliable at 133rd and 102nd, respectively.

Thailand? They're way up there in 17th place overall. Their rank in "starting a business" is just 78th, but they're impressively entrenched in 13th and 14th as far as "protecting investors" and "dealing with construction permits" are concerned. If you were at the helm of a car company, which country would you pick for your manufacturing base if you had to choose between the Philippines and Thailand?

The problem with our country is that almost everyone is on the take--from barangay councilors to mayors all the way up to governors and congressmen. A multinational company has yet to lay down the cornerstone of its building, and already it's coughing up dough to extortionists left and right. Heck, even broadcast journalists who profess to work for public service get in on the act, too, harassing carmakers and asking for brand-new vehicles in exchange for their "silence" on bogus consumer complaints.

Word has it that the Philippine Automotive Competitiveness Council--a coalition of car companies lobbying the government on issues affecting the industry--is set to make a clamor for the Aquino administration to take advantage of the current situation in Thailand and convince automakers to set up manufacturing facilities in the country. Frankly, I don't know how they propose to make this happen.

A country under water is still far more attractive than one mired in corruption.

COMMENTS

User account login

Not registered? Click here to be a TopGear.com.ph member.

Forgot your Password?.

Click this link to view our posting guidelines.

Filter comments by:
  • 17Sphynx17 Nov 16 2011 @ 08:06am
    Truth hurts, and this is our reality at present.

    If it changes, then great. If it doesn't, then it just doesn't.

    It's hard to deny that we lack the facilities to entice investors to really put up here as the government alone put a long and very large red tape they have to pass through, not just one, but a lot and it continues to be brought out every single year. Sad but true.
  • usbao_26 Nov 16 2011 @ 08:25am
    I definitely agree to that!
  • vinci24 Nov 16 2011 @ 08:31am
    "The problem with our country is that almost everyone is on the take--from barangay councilors to mayors all the way up to governors and congressmen."

    True enough. I do have a brother-in-law who is a constructor and he told me the same thing.
  • redcat Nov 16 2011 @ 09:27am
    so true. i myself is a testament to that. im putting up a gas station and im already on my 7th month of securing my permits but nothing yet is concrete up to now because i refuse to give grease money. ALMOST every signature you need needs grease money , from the lowest to the highest official. ............God save the Phil
    • hajabah Nov 16 2011 @ 04:41pm
      sorry if my guess is way off the mark, but is this gas station on Ortigas in San Juan, by any chance?
  • Jetwash Nov 16 2011 @ 09:28am
    Everything you said is true sir. Everybody is on the take. Baranggay capt., police, municipal officers, even NPA are all asking money. It is so difficult to start a business here. Our system sucks.
  • aargh Nov 16 2011 @ 09:43am
    Kung walang nagbibigay, walang manghuhuthot...Most Pinoys kasi gusto shortcut lagi. Kahit renewal lang ng license pinapalakad pa. Traffic violation inaareglo pa. Maliit na bagay lng yun, how much more kung bigger things pa like putting up a business? Malakas loob ng mga corrupt officials kasi mas marami parin willing to bribe kesa dun sa ayaw.
  • sani19 Nov 16 2011 @ 10:17am
    Sir vbsarne, I'm just curious what is our country's rank in "paying taxes"? https://spn.sr/Uwg
  • Aloha Milkyway Nov 16 2011 @ 11:31am
    A country under water is still far more attractive than one mired in corruption. - SWAK
  • cyndi Nov 16 2011 @ 11:55am
    I must say that I feel bad for monkeys. They're simply mischievous while humans willfully do much worse! ;)
  • mindkinetic Nov 16 2011 @ 02:01pm
    this vicious cycle of corruption will remain a perennial problem until the possibility of a charter change. our economic laws are bordering between archaic and so so . what needs to be done is the promulgation of new economic laws that is conducive for business. seconded by quality education, we are 2ND from the bottom in a 2009 survey in math compared to countries in our region. likewise English efficiency has declined to about 30% in the country. over all the picture is not encouraging and this can be likened to a MONTERO its all hot from the exterior but the engine needs to be perked up.
  • mts Nov 16 2011 @ 02:06pm
    That's also one factor why cars here are very expensive compared to other countries. That's also a big factor why there are a lot of proprietors or corporations who are trying to tax evade.
  • usbao_26 Nov 16 2011 @ 04:03pm
    When you are in a construction business, its very common that when your bidding on a govt. project its likely that you'll get pass by other contractors because they have already bribe the govt. officials..Have seen so many of these things here in our Town.
  • hajabah Nov 16 2011 @ 04:43pm
    Your last sentence says it all. Good job, vbs. Now if the officials looked away from their kickbacks and glanced at your article... wait. Never will happen, huh.
  • lsdgenie Nov 16 2011 @ 06:03pm
    The problem isn't the corruption - its the lack of consistency in dealing with the government.

    From personal experience, there is corruption in practically all developing countries (including Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia...heck even in Korea and First World Countries) in putting up a business. Most MNC's know this, and even factor it into their business costs.

    What annoys and turns-off most Big businesses from the country is, even after paying a set of "fees" to certain officials to get their start up business permits in order...they have to pay another round of "fees" every election/change of administration/appointed personnel to continue doing business. Worse, their very existence may be even declared "unlawful"...just because political winds change (which entails another round of "fees" to deal with). Even worse, the government may shut down their business and take it over.

    With scenarios like this happening - why would I take the chance of putting up a $900 Million dollar factory here?

    Consistency.
    • pup2 Nov 18 2011 @ 05:01pm
      I agree. Not only that, why would you put up a manufacturing business here when:

      1) You will be a prime target of both BIR and DOLE;
      2) Your electricity rates are higher than Japan;
      3) Your labor cost isn't that cheap and is prone to KMU-intrusion;
      4) Your fixed, Land & Improvements aren't that hot, and;
      5) Basically, everyone's out to crab your business downward!

      Philippine manufacturing, not just automotive production, is DEAD. The only ones turning a (great) profit are either monopolies or oligopolies. What manufacturing we USED to have has already left.
  • bruce Nov 16 2011 @ 06:59pm
    so sad! everyone knows this but nobody cares! everyone is so busy earning money to be able to survive.. taxes supposedly will help the government but were being stolen.. at pinamimigay pa sa mga rebelde!
  • Kim John Nov 16 2011 @ 07:11pm
    nakakahinayang lang kasi pilipino engineers is way better than those thailanders. if only p-noy can convince those car makers set there manufacturing facilities here.
  • mts Nov 16 2011 @ 07:32pm
    @Kim John: Sir, maybe they're not just considering the current President but also the future. In general, previous Presidents are corrupt. So maybe, PNoy alone isn't enough.

    @lsdgenie: Sir, I agree with you that all countries are corrupt. But one question is, how corrupt are they? And how corrupt is the Phil. Gov't? Let me put it this way, corruption is not the only reason but it is one big factor.

    @Redcat: I agree with you! Save Phil. :))

    @Vinci24: Governors and Congressmen? May I know where's that? :) From my experience, Congressmen = Pork Barrel and Governors = Gov't Projects. I thought that unless its a big business, they're off the hook..
  • mts Nov 16 2011 @ 07:33pm
    Oh, and also Gov = Jueteng and the likes. :))
  • trilobyt Nov 16 2011 @ 10:20pm
    amen to that. Very well said sir Vernon... This is also very true for other industries, not only in automotive manufacturing... now if only our politicians can read this. but would they really care for anything except fattening their pockets?
  • JoHunter Nov 17 2011 @ 07:59am
    *sigh*

    This is exactly what I have in mind the first time I read that ranking of easiest countries to conduct business. We place so low because our government willfully embraces the cacophony of red tape it now has to give plenty of chance for takes. "Hopeless" is too kind a word to describe our country's woeful situation.

    Are there any government officials reading this? If so, siguro wala na rin pag-asa kasi masyado nang makapal ang mukha nila to be affected by articles like this. What our country really needs to have a fighting chance is for these bloodsuckers to simply drop dead where they stand.
  • wart_les Nov 17 2011 @ 11:04am
    The Philippines NEEDS more like a MARIO MONTI and perhaps DANILO LIM alike...When a government like PNOY has FRUGALITY in saving, people and the so called economist will COMPLAIN on underspending because the GDP is in dismal growth?
    When a genius Bobby Ongpin borrowed money easily from DBP and pocketed huge some in stock TRADING, it is called above board for as long the bank made PROFIT too?
    When a PLUNDERER found guilty by the court is being pardoned by the President?
    When a person is to be investigated for none bailable offense will go out of the country citing health reason and constitutional rights to travel?
    I supposed the answer with this MONKEY business is TSUNAMI because we like democracy and simply the system does not work in REALITY...Filipinos are disciplined in SAUDI but not in the Philippines?
  • nestortinam Nov 17 2011 @ 01:19pm
    2 days lang di na update iyon books of account, BIR wants 8500, sobra naman, nagkasakit iyon tao babayag pa ng penalty.
    Sadly the Gov't should go after those who are not issuing official receipt, not the one who are issuing 100% receipt, this happen to my friend. After checking all receipt no finding tapos gusto pa humiingi pera.
  • rcaballero Nov 17 2011 @ 01:56pm
    I agree... ang problema kasi sa pakikipag deal sa mga government offices para sa pagkuha ng business permits etc... halos lahat ng mesa na dadaanan mo hihingan ka ng lagay.
  • cryss Nov 22 2011 @ 10:21am
    Bullseye!!! Straight in the middle. Thou politicians won't be affected. In automotive dictionary, napakakapal na ng masilya sa mukha nila kaya di na ma-aapektuhan. Truth is eventhough you are paying your taxes with all honesty and religiously, when these BIR officials needed money, they'll just send you a letter. Review your books (or pretend to look at it) but bottom line is when they wanted to look at your books, they just wanted you to pay "fees". Question - How can a BIR district officer earning this or that amount of salary monthly afford to buy a big house(most of the time more than one) and have a lot of cars(mostly suv's or luxury cars) ?
    Still, even with this situation at hand, P-noy is trying to do something. This situation gives us Filipinos HOPE. P-noy may not be able to change everything during his term but it is worth a try. And we still hope this situation can be fixed in the future. Could be soon or maybe not in my lifetime. But still there's hope.
Filter comments by:
1 to 20 of 24